Judging

Our esteemed judges include the following:

Virgoian, Tradermare, peppermintyrose, VAlady, 88spike


Your story will be judged based on writing style, diction, dialog, story structure, creativity, and spelling/grammar. The top two will be awarded prizes, with one award also being given to the best virgin writer.

Fan Voting:

There will be an open round of public voting on Fanftion.net with the fan favorites being chosen, the top two will receive prizes. There will also be one story chosen by the hosts to receive a prize.


Here's a breakdown of how stories will be judged:




CATEGORY
GUIDELINES
Max. Points
Points Given
Writing
Overall quality of the writing; style and narration is believable and compelling; story flows; clear point of view; consistent tone; credible plot with no “holes”; keeps the reader engaged
20

Grammar/ Usage/ Mechanics/ Spelling

Story is free from spelling and punctuation errors; no run-ons or fragments (unless warranted by artistic style of the story); avoids repetitive words; varies sentence structure
10

Diction
Author avoids misused words, awkward language and wordiness; writing is clear in its meaning
10

Characters
Main characters are well-developed, convincingly created and described, with sufficient depth for a one-shot
10

Dialogue
Incorporated smoothly within narrative; seems appropriate for characters, whether canon or AU
10

Structure/ Organization
Clear format, easy to follow plotline; flashbacks are integrated well (if used); story builds to a climax and includes resolution; seems ‘complete’ as a one-shot
10

Creativity
Original storyline; creative use of characters and plot, twist, and/or narrative style
10

Emotional Impact
Story engages and connects with reader, leaves lasting impression; the “WOW” factor
15

Research/ Historically Accurate
Story is researched and factual; plot well researched and historically correct
5

FINAL SCORE


100